My league is wrapping up its first season (5 guys, play each other twice, playoffs start next week). Three guys are new to EF, and one other played it as a kid. It's primarily a beer league kind of thing, so I have kept gameplay simple--only stop is for passing (using sticks) to keep it fun.
We have used an automatic punt rule: receiving team gets the ball 55 yards downfield if punting team is on their side of the 50, 35 yards if on the receiving side of the 50 (touchbacks happen of course). But I want to add the element of a return.
For kickoffs, I developed a system that works pretty well: kicking team lines up at or behind the 50, receiving team has 5 on the 40, 4 on the 20, and two returners on the goal line. Ball is dropped between the receivers, and the closer guy is the return man. Pivot players and run the board. Results are realistic.
We were toying with ideas to make punt returns a part of the game, such as maybe starting 5 coverage guys say 30 yards down field, keeping the 5 interior linemen at the original LOS and the punter behind them. Receiving team would put 5 men on LOS, cover the 5 guys downfield where they are, and put a return man 60 yards deep. Punting coach drops the ball from above the yard line where the return man is, move the return man to where the ball ends up, everyone pivots, then run the board.
Thoughts and suggestions?